Crafting an Intricate Mystery

October 2024 Newsletter

The mystery genre has held people in its tight grasp for quite some time now. From the board game Clue, to classic Christie novels, to more modern magic cozies, it is a genre that people love.  But what exactly makes a mystery so compelling? And how do different subgenres like thrillers and cozy mysteries stack up? In this month’s newsletter we will examine what key elements are needed to create a successful mystery.

---

MODULE 1: UNDERSTANDING THE ANATOMY OF A MYSTERY

Photo by Volodymyr Hryshchenko on Unsplash

What Makes a Mystery?

Defining the Mystery Genre: Mystery, Thriller, and Cozy Mystery

The dictionary defines mystery as something that is difficult or impossible to understand which suits our needs just fine. At its core, a mystery revolves around a crime that needs to be solved. Typically, the plot follows a detective (amateur or professional) as they uncover clues, interview suspects, and eventually solve the case. But not all mysteries are created equal. There are several subgenres within mystery, each with its unique feel, pacing, and tone.

• Mystery: In a traditional mystery, the focus is on solving the crime. The reader follows the detective as they gather clues, and the resolution usually has a logical conclusion that is satisfying to the reader based on the plot they read.

• Thriller: A thriller emphasizes suspense and tension on top of the mystery element. In thrillers, the protagonist is often racing against time to prevent a catastrophe, and the stakes are higher and more intense. Thrillers can often take a much darker turn and can deal with more serious and dramatic subject matters.

• Cozy Mystery: This subgenre takes away the grit and grime of the crime and focuses on lighter subjects. The crimes are generally less violent, and the amateur sleuths are everyday people with everyday professions. Cozies are as much about the community and quirky characters as they are about the central mystery.